Cabinet Refacing vs. New Cabinets in Markham: Which Is Right for You?

If you're a Markham homeowner weighing whether to choose the lower-cost cabinet refacing or invest in full custom new cabinets, this article provides a detailed comparison across costs, durability, timelines, and local permit rules. Our quick verdict will help you decide based on your budget and kitchen condition.

Further reading

• Kitchen renovation in Markham
• Cabinet refacing
• Milton cabinet refacing guide
• Complete Mississauga kitchen renovation cost guide
• Quartz vs granite countertop comparison

Quick Verdict for Different Homeowner Types

In Markham, many homeowners face the same question: should you choose the lower-cost cabinet refacing or invest in full custom new cabinets? The answer depends on your needs, budget, and the condition of your existing kitchen.

• Budget-conscious, structurally intact cabinets: If your existing cabinet boxes are structurally sound, without water damage or warping, and you are satisfied with the current layout, cabinet refacing is the most economical choice. In 2025, refacing in Markham costs approximately $5,000–$12,000 CAD, with a timeline of only 5–10 days.
• Layout changes needed, aging boxes: If you want to change the kitchen workflow, add an island, or replace old boxes, full custom cabinetry is a better investment. Costs range from $15,000 to $35,000 CAD, with a timeline of 4–8 weeks, but you get complete customization.
• Rental property or quick resale: Refacing can quickly enhance the kitchen's appearance, increasing property appeal at a lower cost. Many Markham landlords choose this option.
• High-end custom needs: If you demand premium materials or special features (e.g., built-in wine racks, lift-up cabinets), full custom is the only way to go.

Whichever option you choose, Josh Kitchen can provide professional advice and installation. Call (647) 838-1083 for a free consultation.

Comparison Table: Cabinet Refacing vs. Full Replacement

Option A: Cabinet Refacing – Pros and Cons

Pros

• Lower cost: Saves 40-60% compared to full custom, ideal for tight budgets.
• Fast timeline: Completed in 5-10 days, minimal disruption to daily life.
• Eco-friendly: Reduces landfill waste from old cabinets, aligning with green renovation trends.
• No permit needed: Markham typically does not require a building permit for pure refacing, reducing paperwork.

Cons

• Cannot change layout: You cannot move cabinet positions or alter kitchen workflow.
• Box condition dependency: Existing boxes must be in good shape; otherwise, issues may appear soon after refacing.
• Limited material choices: Only doors, drawer fronts, and veneers can be replaced; interior box upgrades are not possible.
• Lower value increase: Compared to full custom, refacing adds less to property value.

Josh Kitchen offers a variety of finish options, including thermal transfer laminate and painted finishes, ensuring a long-lasting and beautiful result.

Option B: Full Custom Cabinetry – Pros and Cons

Pros

• Complete customization: Design every aspect—size, material, and functionality—to your exact needs.
• Higher property value: A high-end custom kitchen is a selling point in Markham's luxury market.
• Exceptional durability: Solid wood or premium MDF boxes can last 20-30 years.
• Layout freedom: Reimagine islands, wall cabinets, tall cabinets, and more.

Cons

• Higher cost: Starting at $15,000, high-end projects can exceed $35,000.
• Longer timeline: 4-8 weeks, during which the kitchen is unusable.
• Permit requirements: Structural changes require a permit from the Markham building department.
• More disruption: Demolition, electrical, and plumbing work create noise and dust.

Josh Kitchen's full custom service covers everything from design to installation, ensuring every detail meets your expectations.

Cost and Durability in Markham (2025 CAD)

Below are typical cost ranges for Markham kitchen renovations in 2025, including materials and labor (excluding appliances).

Note: These are estimates. Actual costs vary based on material selection and complexity. Contact Josh Kitchen for a free on-site measurement and quote.

Frequently Asked Questions About Cabinet Refacing in Markham

1. Can cabinet refacing change the cabinet color?
   Yes, refacing replaces doors and veneers, allowing any color or wood grain. However, interior box color usually stays the same.
2. Is refaced cabinetry durable?
   With high-quality finishes (e.g., thermal transfer or UV paint), refaced cabinets can last 10-15 years. Avoid moisture and scratches.
3. Do I need a permit from the City of Markham for refacing?
   Generally no, since refacing does not involve structural changes. However, if plumbing or electrical work is involved, consult the Markham building department.
4. Can I reface again later?
   Yes, but multiple refacings may weaken the cabinet boxes. It's generally recommended to replace after two refacings.
5. Does refacing affect home resale value in Markham?
   Refacing can improve kitchen appearance and positively impact resale, but the value increase is typically less than full custom. In Markham, buyers prefer solid wood or premium finishes.
6. How long does refacing last compared to new cabinets?
   With proper care, refaced cabinets last 10-15 years, while full custom cabinets can last 20-30 years.

Ready to Transform Your Kitchen? Get a Free Consultation

Whether you choose cabinet refacing or full custom, Josh Kitchen can provide the right solution. We serve Markham and the Greater Toronto Area, offering free on-site measurement and design consultation. Call (647) 838-1083 today to schedule your appointment! Let us give your kitchen a new lease on life.